První Intel Pentium 4 je zklamáním ve 3D Mark

Firma Intel 20. listopadu roku 2000 uvedla na trh své první procesory Pentium 4 s nejvyšší frekvencí 1500MHz, přičemž to číslo v té době vzbuzovalo respekt. Naproti tomu Pentium 3 vcházelo do své závěrečné fáze, aspoň tedy co se týče výrobního procesu 180nm a zde v testech je předposlední model na frekvenci 1100MHz. Rozdíl mezi nimi je tedy 400MHz, což v té době bylo opravdu hodně, neboť odstup jednotlivých modelů Pentium 3 stoupal v mezích 33 nebo 50MHz a až u Pentium 4 to bylo většinou po 100MHz. Přesto když proběhnete tabulky, kde jsou výkony s různými grafickými kartami, není rozdíl nijak zásadní a spíše jsou vyrovnané. A když se k tomu připočte 33 Watt, které tepelně vyzařuje Pentium 3 proti 55 Watt u Pentium 4, tak je efektivita i dobová cena jasně na straně Pentium 3.

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
Frekvence	1.5	–	1.1	GHz
Rychlost sběrnice	100	–	100	MHz
Násobič	14	–	11	krát
Napětí	1.7	–	1.75	voltů
L1 Cache	20	–	32	KB
L2 Cache	256	–	256	KB
Socket (Patice)	423	–	370	pin
Multimediální Instrukce	MMX/SSE/SSE2	–	MMX/SSE
Název jádra	Willamette	–	Coppermine
Identifikační kód	SL4TY	–	SL5QW	série
Uveden na trh	11/2000	–	06/2000	měsíc/rok
Výrobní technologie	180	–	180	nm
TDP	55	–	33	watt
Cena	32700	–	13664	Kč

Testováno na

V této tabulce jsou výsledky, které jsem provedl v minulosti s deskou Elitegroup P4VXADS, která má sloty DDR RAM, ale neumožňovala přetaktování procesoru.

TESTY CPU + RAM
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz DDR		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz SDR
CPU Mark 2.1
CPU Mark 2.1	2035.4	–	2114.2	Final Score
Test 1 – Registry	1008.4	–	504.2	Score
Test 2 – Plovoucí čárka	100.8	–	289.8	Score
Test 3 – Celá čísla	1939.2	–	2100.8	Score
AIDA32 ver.3.80
RAM čtení	1933	–	769	MB/s
RAM zápis	525	–	218	MB/s
AIDA64 Extreme Edition ver.2.60
RAM čtení	1901	–	786	MB/s
RAM zápis	2013	–	782	MB/s
RAM kopírování	1135	–	610	MB/s
RAM latence	180.8	–	134.5	ns
CPU Queen	1520	–	2113	Score
CPU PhotoWorxx	1052	–	905	Score
CPU Zlib	10	–	8.5	MB/s
CPU AES	1372	–	1544	Score
CPU Hash	138	–	108	MB/s
FPU VP8	196	–	186	Score
FPU Julia	517	–	241	Score
FPU Mandel	265	–	85	Score
FPU SinJulia	164	–	179	Score

Výkon po přetaktování CPU

TESTY CPU + RAM
Intel Pentium 4 1.78GHz SDR		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.3GHz SDR
CPU Mark 2.1
CPU Mark 2.1	2409.7	–	2523.9	Final Score
Test 1 – Registry	1200.5	–	586.3	Score
Test 2 – Plovoucí čárka	120.0	–	340.7	Score
Test 3 – Celá čísla	2291.8	–	2521.0	Score
AIDA32 ver.3.80
RAM čtení	1214	–	906	MB/s
RAM zápis	492	–	255	MB/s
AIDA64 Extreme Edition ver.2.60
RAM čtení	1229	–	924	MB/s
RAM zápis	1129	–	921	MB/s
RAM kopírování	1001	–	683	MB/s
RAM latence	140.8	–	114.1	ns
CPU Queen	1826	–	2487	Score
CPU PhotoWorxx	1187	–	1043	Score
CPU Zlib	11.9	–	11.1	MB/s
CPU AES	1636	–	1812	Score
CPU Hash	165	–	127	MB/s
FPU VP8	231	–	166	Score
FPU Julia	617	–	284	Score
FPU Mandel	317	–	100	Score
FPU SinJulia	195	–	211	Score

Grafický výkon po přetaktování s nVidia GeForce3

Intel Pentium 4 1.78GHz SDR		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.3GHz SDR
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	8136	–	8313	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	21298	–	18058	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	98.2	–	99.3	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	69.5	–	71.5	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	7452	–	7660	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	68.6	–	68.7	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	50.5	–	53.5	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5956	–	5619	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	30.4	–	30.1	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	51.6	–	46.2	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	42.8	–	41.8	FPS
Game 4 – Nature	34.4	–	31.8	FPS

Výkon na jednotlivých grafických kartách:

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	3232	–	5863	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	18159	–	15398	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	31.0	–	64.7	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	33.7	–	53.6	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	1812	–	1820	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	12.1	–	12.1	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	25.0	–	25.4	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	1301	–	1264	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	8.7	–	9.0	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	9.6	–	8.4	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	12.7	–	12.6	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	4406	–	4305	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	17507	–	15328	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	43.2	–	43.3	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	44.9	–	42.8	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	4518	–	4520	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	31.0	–	31.0	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	38.1	–	38.9	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	2914	–	2738	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	18.2	–	17.4	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	23.2	–	20.1	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	26.5	–	25.4	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5269	–	5076	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	18177	–	16353	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	54.8	–	54.4	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	50.7	–	47.6	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5803	–	5689	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	46.6	–	45.6	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	41.6	–	42.1	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	3660	–	3185	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	22.4	–	21.0	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	26.8	–	19.0	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	30.0	–	27.3	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5577	–	5875	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	17740	–	15253	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	58.6	–	68.9	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	53.2	–	51.2	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	6612	–	6236	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	59.6	–	55.9	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	44.3	–	43.9	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5897	–	5564	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	27.5	–	25.7	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	61.6	–	59.2	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	36.2	–	34.3	FPS
Game 4 – Nature	32.4	–	29.6	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5722	–	6166	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	17681	–	15296	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	59.5	–	71.9	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	55.1	–	54.0	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	6694	–	6363	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	68.3	–	60.8	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	43.0	–	43.2	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5725	–	5410	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	26.4	–	25.9	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	54.0	–	51.8	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	36.8	–	35.1	FPS
Game 4 – Nature	35.5	–	30.9	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	4858	–	5031	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	17905	–	15274	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	47.0	–	48.2	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	50.2	–	52.6	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	3888	–	3948	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	26.1	–	26.4	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	36.6	–	38.5	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	2850	–	2791	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	17.7	–	18.3	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	21.5	–	19.5	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	26.5	–	26.6	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	6310	–	6355	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	18299	–	16297	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	66.3	–	66.0	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	60.2	–	61.3	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5826	–	5895	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	46.3	–	46.0	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	43.6	–	45.2	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	3869	–	3672	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	20.9	–	20.1	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	33.2	–	29.6	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	31.2	–	30.0	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	4415	–	4508	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	17943	–	15315	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	40.4	–	41.8	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	48.7	–	48.9	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	3419	–	3466	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	24.9	–	24.7	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	35.3	–	37.2	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	2684	–	2658	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	17.7	–	18.4	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	21.6	–	20.4	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	24.4	–	24.6	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	7076	–	7315	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	17895	–	15262	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	85.1	–	87.3	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	60.6	–	62.9	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	6128	–	6883	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	60.2	–	65.7	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	41.3	–	46.3	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5229	–	5023	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	23.7	–	24.6	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	48.4	–	44.0	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	35.4	–	35.4	FPS
Game 4 – Nature	33.1	–	30.4	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5894	–	6069	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	17796	–	15328	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	61.1	–	62.0	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	56.9	–	59.5	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5238	–	5404	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	38.8	–	40.1	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	40.8	–	43.8	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	3544	–	3486	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	20.0	–	20.4	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	28.7	–	27.2	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	29.4	–	29.7	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	7257	–	7448	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	17782	–	15268	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	85.6	–	86.1	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	63.0	–	65.6	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	6362	–	6703	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	62.5	–	61.8	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	41.1	–	45.0	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	6357	–	6516	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	24.3	–	25.5	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	71.9	–	72.5	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	35.8	–	36.2	FPS
Game 4 – Nature	41.4	–	41.9	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	7034	–	7296	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	17917	–	15332	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	79.9	–	86.5	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	62.8	–	63.1	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	6193	–	6651	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	52.6	–	57.1	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	40.4	–	45.0	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	4266	–	4133	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	22.4	–	24.3	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	38.7	–	32.9	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	31.7	–	30.8	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5838	–	6718	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	18002	–	15355	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	59.2	–	72.7	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	57.1	–	62.4	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	3913	–	4004	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	25.7	–	26.2	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	37.1	–	39.8	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	1968	–	1924	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	12.3	–	12.8	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	13.7	–	12.8	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	16.5	–	16.4	FPS

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz		vs.	Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	5883	–	7541	3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed	18138	–	15311	3D Marks
Game 1 – Race	59.9	–	83.9	FPS
Game 2 – First Person	57.8	–	68.5	FPS
3D Mark 2000		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	4789	–	5057	3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail	27.5	–	29.0	FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail	37.2	–	40.1	FPS
3D Mark 2001		–	1024×768/32
Final Score	2132	–	2089	3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail	12.5	–	13.1	FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail	14.7	–	13.7	FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail	20.0	–	20.1	FPS