První Intel Pentium 4 je zklamáním ve 3D Mark

Publikováno Aktualizováno Od ClousKategorie:Porovnávací testy

Firma Intel 20. listopadu roku 2000 uvedla na trh své první procesory Pentium 4 s nejvyšší frekvencí 1500MHz, přičemž to číslo v té době vzbuzovalo respekt. Naproti tomu Pentium 3 vcházelo do své závěrečné fáze, aspoň tedy co se týče výrobního procesu 180nm a zde v testech je předposlední model na frekvenci 1100MHz. Rozdíl mezi nimi je tedy 400MHz, což v té době bylo opravdu hodně, neboť odstup jednotlivých modelů Pentium 3 stoupal v mezích 33 nebo 50MHz a až u Pentium 4 to bylo většinou po 100MHz. Přesto když proběhnete tabulky, kde jsou výkony s různými grafickými kartami, není rozdíl nijak zásadní a spíše jsou vyrovnané. A když se k tomu připočte 33 Watt, které tepelně vyzařuje Pentium 3 proti 55 Watt u Pentium 4, tak je efektivita i dobová cena jasně na straně Pentium 3.

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
Frekvence 1.5 – 1.1 GHz
Rychlost sběrnice 100 – 100 MHz
Násobič 14 – 11 krát
Napětí 1.7 – 1.75 voltů
L1 Cache 20 – 32 KB
L2 Cache 256 – 256 KB
Socket (Patice) 423 – 370 pin
Multimediální Instrukce MMX/SSE/SSE2 – MMX/SSE  
Název jádra Willamette – Coppermine  
Identifikační kód SL4TY – SL5QW série
Uveden na trh 11/2000 – 06/2000 měsíc/rok
Výrobní technologie 180 – 180 nm
TDP 55 – 33 watt
Cena 32700 – 13664 Kč

Testováno na

V této tabulce jsou výsledky, které jsem provedl v minulosti s deskou Elitegroup P4VXADS, která má sloty DDR RAM, ale neumožňovala přetaktování procesoru.

TESTY CPU + RAM
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz DDR vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz SDR
CPU Mark 2.1
CPU Mark 2.1 2035.4 – 2114.2 Final Score
Test 1 – Registry 1008.4 – 504.2 Score
Test 2 – Plovoucí čárka 100.8 – 289.8 Score
Test 3 – Celá čísla 1939.2 – 2100.8 Score
AIDA32 ver.3.80
RAM čtení 1933 – 769 MB/s
RAM zápis 525 – 218 MB/s
AIDA64 Extreme Edition ver.2.60
RAM čtení 1901 – 786 MB/s
RAM zápis 2013 – 782 MB/s
RAM kopírování 1135 – 610 MB/s
RAM latence 180.8 – 134.5 ns
CPU Queen 1520 – 2113 Score
CPU PhotoWorxx 1052 – 905 Score
CPU Zlib 10 – 8.5 MB/s
CPU AES 1372 – 1544 Score
CPU Hash 138 – 108 MB/s
FPU VP8 196 – 186 Score
FPU Julia 517 – 241 Score
FPU Mandel 265 – 85 Score
FPU SinJulia 164 – 179 Score

Výkon po přetaktování CPU

TESTY CPU + RAM
Intel Pentium 4 1.78GHz SDR vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.3GHz SDR
CPU Mark 2.1
CPU Mark 2.1 2409.7 – 2523.9 Final Score
Test 1 – Registry 1200.5 – 586.3 Score
Test 2 – Plovoucí čárka 120.0 – 340.7 Score
Test 3 – Celá čísla 2291.8 – 2521.0 Score
AIDA32 ver.3.80
RAM čtení 1214 – 906 MB/s
RAM zápis 492 – 255 MB/s
AIDA64 Extreme Edition ver.2.60
RAM čtení 1229 – 924 MB/s
RAM zápis 1129 – 921 MB/s
RAM kopírování 1001 – 683 MB/s
RAM latence 140.8 – 114.1 ns
CPU Queen 1826 – 2487 Score
CPU PhotoWorxx 1187 – 1043 Score
CPU Zlib 11.9 – 11.1 MB/s
CPU AES 1636 – 1812 Score
CPU Hash 165 – 127 MB/s
FPU VP8 231 – 166 Score
FPU Julia 617 – 284 Score
FPU Mandel 317 – 100 Score
FPU SinJulia 195 – 211 Score

Grafický výkon po přetaktování s nVidia GeForce3

Intel Pentium 4 1.78GHz SDR vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.3GHz SDR
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 8136 – 8313 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 21298 – 18058 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 98.2 – 99.3 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 69.5 – 71.5 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 7452 – 7660 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 68.6 – 68.7 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 50.5 – 53.5 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5956 – 5619 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 30.4 – 30.1 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 51.6 – 46.2 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 42.8 – 41.8 FPS
Game 4 – Nature 34.4 –  31.8 FPS

Výkon na jednotlivých grafických kartách:

Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 3232 – 5863 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 18159 – 15398 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 31.0 – 64.7 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 33.7 – 53.6 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 1812 – 1820 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 12.1 – 12.1 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 25.0 – 25.4 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 1301 – 1264 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 8.7 – 9.0 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 9.6 – 8.4 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 12.7 – 12.6 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 4406 – 4305 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 17507 – 15328 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 43.2 – 43.3 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 44.9 – 42.8 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 4518 – 4520 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 31.0 – 31.0 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 38.1 – 38.9 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 2914 – 2738 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 18.2 – 17.4 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 23.2 – 20.1 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 26.5 – 25.4 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5269 – 5076 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 18177 – 16353 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 54.8 – 54.4 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 50.7 – 47.6 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5803 – 5689 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 46.6 – 45.6 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 41.6 – 42.1 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 3660 – 3185 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 22.4 – 21.0 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 26.8 – 19.0 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 30.0 – 27.3 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5577 – 5875 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 17740 – 15253 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 58.6 – 68.9 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 53.2 – 51.2 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 6612 – 6236 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 59.6 – 55.9 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 44.3 – 43.9 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5897 – 5564 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 27.5 – 25.7 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 61.6 – 59.2 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 36.2 – 34.3 FPS
Game 4 – Nature 32.4 –  29.6 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5722 – 6166 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 17681 – 15296 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 59.5 – 71.9 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 55.1 – 54.0 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 6694 – 6363 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 68.3 – 60.8 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 43.0 – 43.2 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5725 – 5410 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 26.4 – 25.9 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 54.0 – 51.8 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 36.8 – 35.1 FPS
Game 4 – Nature 35.5 –  30.9 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 4858 – 5031 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 17905 – 15274 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 47.0 – 48.2 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 50.2 – 52.6 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 3888 – 3948 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 26.1 – 26.4 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 36.6 – 38.5 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 2850 – 2791 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 17.7 – 18.3 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 21.5 – 19.5 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 26.5 – 26.6 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 6310 – 6355 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 18299 – 16297 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 66.3 – 66.0 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 60.2 – 61.3 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5826 – 5895 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 46.3 – 46.0 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 43.6 – 45.2 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 3869 – 3672 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 20.9 – 20.1 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 33.2 – 29.6 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 31.2 – 30.0 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 4415 – 4508 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 17943 – 15315 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 40.4 – 41.8 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 48.7 – 48.9 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 3419 – 3466 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 24.9 – 24.7 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 35.3 – 37.2 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 2684 – 2658 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 17.7 – 18.4 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 21.6 – 20.4 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 24.4 – 24.6 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 7076 – 7315 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 17895 – 15262 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 85.1 – 87.3 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 60.6 – 62.9 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 6128 – 6883 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 60.2 – 65.7 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 41.3 – 46.3 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5229 – 5023 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 23.7 – 24.6 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 48.4 – 44.0 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 35.4 – 35.4 FPS
Game 4 – Nature 33.1 –  30.4 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5894 – 6069 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 17796 – 15328 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 61.1 – 62.0 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 56.9 – 59.5 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5238 – 5404 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 38.8 – 40.1 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 40.8 – 43.8 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 3544 – 3486 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 20.0 – 20.4 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 28.7 – 27.2 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 29.4 – 29.7 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 7257 – 7448 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 17782 – 15268 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 85.6 – 86.1 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 63.0 – 65.6 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 6362 – 6703 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 62.5 – 61.8 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 41.1 – 45.0 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 6357 – 6516 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 24.3 – 25.5 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 71.9 – 72.5 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 35.8 – 36.2 FPS
Game 4 – Nature 41.4 –  41.9 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 7034 – 7296 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 17917 – 15332 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 79.9 – 86.5 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 62.8 – 63.1 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 6193 – 6651 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 52.6 – 57.1 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 40.4 – 45.0 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 4266 – 4133 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 22.4 – 24.3 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 38.7 – 32.9 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 31.7 – 30.8 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5838 – 6718 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 18002 – 15355 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 59.2 – 72.7 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 57.1 – 62.4 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 3913 – 4004 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 25.7 – 26.2 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 37.1 – 39.8 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 1968 – 1924 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 12.3 – 12.8 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 13.7 – 12.8 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 16.5 – 16.4 FPS
Intel Pentium 4 1.5GHz vs. Intel Pentium 3 1.1GHz
3D Mark 1999
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 5883 – 7541 3D Marks
CPU 3D Speed 18138 – 15311 3D Marks
Game 1 – Race 59.9 – 83.9 FPS
Game 2 – First Person 57.8 – 68.5 FPS
3D Mark 2000
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 4789 – 5057 3D Marks
Game 1 – Helicopter – High Detail 27.5 – 29.0 FPS
Game 2 – Adventure – High Detail 37.2 – 40.1 FPS
3D Mark 2001
 – 1024×768/32
Final Score 2132 – 2089 3D Marks
Game 1 – Car Chase – High Detail 12.5 – 13.1 FPS
Game 2 – Dragothic – High Detail 14.7 – 13.7 FPS
Game 3 – Lobby – High Detail 20.0 – 20.1 FPS

Sdílejte!

Clous

www.clous.cz

Stačí kliknout O mně

Čtěte dál

PředchozíDalší

Komentáře

Napsat komentář

Vaše e-mailová adresa nebude zveřejněna. Vyžadované informace jsou označeny *